Revere Pewter HC-172 vs. Agreeable Gray SW 7029: Paint Guide
Choosing the right paint color for your home can be tricky, especially when two shades look so similar.
If you’re torn between Revere Pewter vs. Agreeable Gray, you’re in the right place. Both colors are popular, but each has its own vibe depending on your room’s lighting, finishes, and overall feel.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through the key differences between these two shades so you can make the best choice for your space. From color profiles to ideal room placement, you’ll get the clarity you need.
Understanding Revere Pewter and Agreeable Gray
These two shades may look similar at first glance, but they behave quite differently depending on your light, finishes, and layout.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of each color:
Revere Pewter (HC-172) by Benjamin Moore
Revere Pewter is a warm, versatile beige-gray with soft green undertones. It’s a go-to neutral for traditional and transitional spaces, often used with wood, stone, or earthy textures.
Its grounded feel makes it especially appealing in cozy or rustic homes.
Basic Color Profile
- HEX code: #CBC6B8
- LRV (Light Reflectance Value): 55.98
- Color Family: Warm beige with green-beige undertones
This shade belongs to Benjamin Moore’s Historical Color Collection and has been a longtime favorite for its balance of depth and softness.
It can shift noticeably in cooler or low-light spaces, often pulling slightly green, so always test your lighting.
Agreeable Gray (SW 7029) by Sherwin-Williams
Agreeable Gray is a light, balanced taupe-gray that reads warm and soft in most lighting conditions.
It’s extremely popular for its flexibility and works in nearly any room, especially those with open layouts or modern styling.
Basic Color Profile
- HEX code: #D1CBC1
- LRV (Light Reflectance Value): 60
- Color Family: Warm taupe-gray with subtle beige undertones
Agreeable Gray is a strong choice if you want something light but not sterile. It stays consistent in both natural and artificial light, making it an easy pick for full-home use.
Revere Pewter vs. Agreeable Gray: Side-by-Side Look
| Feature | Revere Pewter (Benjamin Moore) | Agreeable Gray (Sherwin-Williams) |
| Color Family | Warm beige with an earthy base | Light taupe-gray with soft warmth |
| Undertones | Subtle green and beige | Taupe with slight warmth, no green |
| LRV | 55.98 (moderate depth) | 60 (slightly lighter) |
| Finish Effect | It feels solid and cozy | It brings a clean, soft look |
| Common Uses | Entryways, dining rooms, exteriors | Living rooms, kitchens, whole homes |
| Lighting Impact | It may read darker in cool or low light | It holds its tone in most lighting setups |
Even small shifts in undertones and light reflectance can significantly alter how these colors appear on your walls. Knowing these details can help you make a better choice.
How Lighting Affects Them
Here’s how Revere Pewter and Agreeable Gray compare under different lighting conditions. Each environment changes how the tones feel.
| Lighting Condition | Revere Pewter | Agreeable Gray |
|---|---|---|
| Daylight | It appears warm and grounded with a slight green undertone | It feels bright, balanced, and soft |
| Warm Light (Evening) | Looks deeper and cozier, emphasizes warmth and depth | Maintains a gentle tone, slightly warmer than in daylight |
| Low Light / Shade | It becomes muted and can feel heavier or more traditional | Reflects more light, creating an open and airy feel |
As shown above, Agreeable Gray offers more consistency, while Revere Pewter shifts noticeably based on lighting and room exposure.
Rooms Where Each Color Works Best
These two greiges shine in different places depending on the layout, lighting, and mood you want to create.
Living Spaces (Living Room, Family Room)
If you want a space that feels warm and grounded, Revere Pewter is perfect for dens or formal living rooms. It adds depth and helps the room feel settled.
Agreeable Gray, on the other hand, gives your space an open, lighter feel, especially in smaller or shared living areas. It reflects light nicely and creates a soft backdrop that doesn’t fight with furniture or decor.
If your space has mixed lighting, Agreeable Gray provides more consistent lighting throughout the day.
Kitchen & Dining Areas
Agreeable Gray is a popular choice for kitchens, especially when paired with white cabinets, light-colored countertops, and open layouts. It keeps the space feeling clean, bright, and modern.
Revere Pewter is better for dining rooms, where it brings a cozier, more intimate tone, especially with wooden tables and warm lighting.
If your kitchen and dining areas are connected, using Agreeable Gray in one and Revere Pewter in the other creates a seamless yet interesting contrast that doesn’t disrupt the flow of the space.
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
Agreeable Gray works beautifully in bedrooms and bathrooms. Its soft, neutral tone supports nearly any decor style and helps create a calm, restful atmosphere.
It doesn’t shift too much to artificial lighting, which is ideal for these private areas. Revere Pewter offers a richer, warmer feel that can make bedrooms feel cozy, especially with wood accents or warm-colored bedding.
In bathrooms, it may feel a little heavier, so it’s best suited for larger or naturally lit spaces. Otherwise, stick with Agreeable Gray.
Exteriors & Outdoor Applications
Revere Pewter performs well outside, particularly on siding, trim, or front doors. It holds up in shaded areas and complements stone or brick beautifully. Its depth gives homes a classic, welcoming appearance.
Agreeable Gray is a bit lighter and may appear washed out in strong sunlight, but it’s a great fit for covered porches, exterior trim, or shaded outdoor areas.
For best results, test both colors in your actual setting, as sunlight can dramatically alter how each shade appears during the day.
Matching Each Color to Your Home Style
Understanding how each shade aligns with your interior style can help you make confident choices.
Traditional & Classic Homes
If your home leans traditional, with crown molding, wood tones, and richer finishes, Revere Pewter adds the warmth and depth you’re likely after. It gives a grounded, classic look that blends beautifully with beige and brown tones.
Agreeable Gray can still work in these settings, but it appears softer and may feel a bit too light unless you add strong contrasts, such as dark trim, patterned rugs, or heavier textures, to balance it out.
Transitional & Modern Farmhouse
You’ll likely find Agreeable Gray to be a great match for transitional and modern farmhouse styles.
Its light, neutral tone plays well with black fixtures, white walls, and wood elements. It helps open up the space without feeling cold. Revere Pewter can complement this look, too, especially on cabinetry or accent walls.
It provides contrast and a bit of warmth, which helps if you’re looking to break up an all-white space without going dark or too bold.
Coastal & Light-Filled Spaces
If you’re going for a coastal vibe or have a space full of natural light, Agreeable Gray is the safer choice.
It feels airy and breezy, holding its color well in sunlit rooms. Pair it with soft blues, sandy neutrals, or pale wood for that relaxed beach look.
Revere Pewter may come off too heavy here, especially in bright spots. Still, it could work nicely in shaded corners or on interior doors for a subtle contrast.
Revere Pewter vs. Agreeable Gray: Similar Colors
Select the ideal trim, accent colors, and wood tones to bring out the best in Revere Pewter or Agreeable Gray.
Agreeable Gray (SW 7029): Closest Matches
Compare Agreeable Gray to similar Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, and Behr colors using LRV, hex code, and tone notes below.
| Color Name | Brand | Hex Code | LRV | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agreeable Gray (SW 7029) | Sherwin-Williams | #D1CBC1 | 60 | Soft taupe-gray; consistent in most lighting |
| Repose Gray (SW 7015) | Sherwin-Williams | #CCC8C1 | 58–59 | Cooler and more neutral in tone |
| Anew Gray (SW-7030) | Sherwin-Williams | #BFB6AA | 47 | Deeper and warmer gray with brown undertones |
| Collingwood (OC-28) | Benjamin Moore | #D3CEC4 | 61.52 | Close match, soft and slightly lighter |
| Silver Drop (7902-C) | Behr | #D8D6CE | ~69 | Light and clean; slightly cooler than Agreeable Gray |
Revere Pewter (HC-172): Closest Matches
See how Revere Pewter compares to its close alternatives across brands, with helpful data on LRV, undertones, and visual depth.
| Color Name (Code) | Brand | Hex Code | LRV | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revere Pewter (HC-172) | Benjamin Moore | #CBC6B8 | 55.51 | Warm beige with green undertones; versatile classic |
| Edgecomb Gray (HC-173) | Benjamin Moore | #DAD1C4 | 63.88 | Lighter and less earthy than Revere Pewter |
| Pashmina (AF-100) | Benjamin Moore | #BBB2A1 | 44.2 | Richer and deeper with a soft brown base |
| Accessible Beige (SW 7036) | Sherwin-Williams | #D1C7B8 | 58 | Warmer beige-gray; often used as SW’s closest match |
| Wheat Bread (720C-3) | Behr | #CDC4B7 | ~56 | Similar in-depth and warmth, slightly softer |
Best Pairings and Trim Suggestions
Once you’ve picked your base color, you’ll need to think about what goes around it. I’ll show you which whites, accents, and wood tones work best to help your space feel balanced and pulled together.
Whites That Work for Trim and Ceilings
If you’re going with Revere Pewter or Agreeable Gray, the right white will bring it all together.
- Alabaster (SW 7008, #EDEAE0) adds softness without going yellow, which is great for a cozy look.
- Pure White (SW 7005, #EDECE6) provides a clean contrast that feels crisp without being overly bright.
- Shoji White (SW 7042, #E6DFD3) sits in between and works if you want something quieter.
You can test each of these next to your main color and see which one fits best.
Accent Colors to Try With Each Shade
Warm tones like terracotta, bronze, dusty rose, or soft olive green bring out the earthy side of Revere Pewter and give the room a natural feel.
For Agreeable Gray, cooler shades like navy, charcoal, and slate blue add contrast and keep things grounded. If you’re after a softer look, mix in muted pastels or light metals.
You don’t need to match perfectly; make sure the accents either echo or contrast your base tone clearly.
Wood Finishes That Bring Balance
Both Revere Pewter and Agreeable Gray pair well with wood. Lighter woods like white oak or birch keep things bright and open. If your space feels too light, add walnut, driftwood, or chestnut to warm it up.
Revere Pewter leans into the warmth of darker finishes, while Agreeable Gray works well with both light and dark wood tones. Try placing a wood sample next to your swatch so you can spot any color clashes before proceeding.
Long-Term Wear and Color Longevity
Paint isn’t just about looks today; it’s about how it performs in the long run. Here’s what to expect from both colors over time.
How Each Color Looks Over Time
Revere Pewter holds steady in low-light areas, giving off a warm, cozy tone. But in bright natural light, it may appear warmer or even take on a faint green cast, especially near large windows.
Agreeable Gray remains more consistent across various lighting conditions. It doesn’t shift much and holds its original tone in most rooms, even after years.
This makes it a reliable option if you want a color that won’t change much as your space evolves.
Resistance to Fading, Yellowing, and Dullness
Agreeable Gray resists fading and yellowing quite well, even in sunny spaces or areas that are frequently cleaned. That makes it ideal for open layouts and high-traffic rooms.
Revere Pewter can last just as long, but it’s more likely to show subtle tone shifts depending on lighting and finish. In some conditions, it may lean greener or slightly darker.
Both colors hold up well with proper care, but if color stability is your priority, Agreeable Gray is more forgiving.
Summing Up
Now that you’ve seen how Revere Pewter and Agreeable Gray differ, you’ve got what you need to choose with confidence.
Consider your lighting, style, and the desired warmth or coolness of the space. Each shade brings its unique strength; it simply depends on what suits your home best.
Test them out in different lighting conditions and choose the one that feels right for your space.
Still torn between colors? Visit other color comparison posts on the website for additional side-by-side comparisons.
