Sherwin-Williams Cashmere vs Super Paint: Honest Review
Sherwin-Williams paints are a favorite for many homeowners, and I’ve used them enough to see why.
I’ve seen plenty of Sherwin-Williams options, and every Cashmere paint review seems to agree that it’s one of the best paint lines with a finish that practically perfects itself.
But Cashmere isn’t the only strong option; SuperPaint has its own loyal fans thanks to its durability and budget-friendly price.
Since I’ve had the chance to try both, I wanted to put them side by side in this honest test.
If you’re torn between Cashmere’s premium look or SuperPaint’s practical value, this comparison might help you figure out which is the better choice for your space.
What Makes Cashmere Stand Out
Sherwin-Williams Cashmere has built its reputation on one main thing: how effortlessly smooth it looks on the wall.
The finish almost feels “buttery,” and thanks to its self-leveling formula, brush and roller marks tend to disappear as it dries.
It gives a soft, luxurious feel that works especially well in living rooms or bedrooms where appearance matters most.
Another thing people notice right away is the feel. Once dry, Cashmere has a soft, almost velvety touch. It’s not something you typically find with standard wall paints, and it lends your space a subtle sense of luxury.
Other highlights of Cashmere include:
- Imperfection-hiding: It conceals small wall flaws, such as bumps or light scratches.
- Versatility: Works well in living rooms, dining rooms, and bedrooms where a polished look is desired.
- Multiple finishes: From flat to pearl, depending on whether you want soft depth or light reflectivity.
Cashmere isn’t the cheapest option in the Sherwin-Williams lineup, but many homeowners are willing to spend a little more for that upscale finish.
What SuperPaint Does Best
SuperPaint, on the other hand, is a workhorse paint. It doesn’t aim to feel luxurious but instead focuses on strength, coverage, and value.
For homeowners who want a reliable paint without breaking the bank, SuperPaint is often the go-to choice.
Some of its strongest qualities include:
- Durability: Resists scrubbing, cleaning, and everyday wear.
- Coverage: Like Cashmere, it usually covers well in two coats.
- Washability: Ideal for high-traffic areas, children’s rooms, or hallways.
- Cost: Less expensive than Cashmere, making it a practical choice for larger projects.
SuperPaint is especially good for areas where walls take a beating. If you have pets running through hallways, kids touching every surface, SuperPaint gets the job done.
Cashmere vs Superpaint: Coverage and Finish
Coverage and finish are often the deciding factors between these two paints.
| Feature | Cashmere | SuperPaint |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Refined, smooth, self-leveling finish | Solid, reliable finish, but not as buttery smooth |
| Ease of Use | Forgiving for beginners; hides roller streaks and small imperfections | Straightforward to apply, but brush/roller marks may be more visible |
| Feel | Soft, velvety touch | Standard paint feel |
| Best Use | Living rooms, dining rooms, and bedrooms where appearance matters | Hallways, kids’ rooms, high-traffic areas where durability matters |
When tested both, Cashmere gave the living room walls a higher-end feel, while SuperPaint worked perfectly in the hallway, where durability mattered more than looks.
Which is Best in Each Area
Paint isn’t just about coverage and cost; it’s about how it works in daily life. Cashmere and SuperPaint both hold up well, but they shine in different rooms for different reasons.
Living Rooms & Bedrooms
Cashmere is at its best in spaces meant to feel polished and inviting. Its self-leveling finish smooths out roller lines and small flaws, which is great in areas where natural light hits the walls.
The result is a calm, refined look that makes furniture and décor stand out without distractions.
Hallways & Entryways
Hallways and entryways see the most traffic, which is where SuperPaint’s durability really helps. It resists scuffs, marks, and dirt that come from daily comings and goings.
A quick wipe with a damp cloth usually restores the walls to like-new condition, making it the more practical choice for these busy, lived-in spaces.
Dining Areas
Cashmere adds a sense of warmth and elegance to dining spaces. The velvety finish creates soft light reflections, which make the room feel cozy yet classy.
It’s an especially good option if you want a welcoming atmosphere during family dinners or gatherings with friends, since the smooth walls bring a subtle touch of formality.
Kids’ Rooms or Playrooms
SuperPaint is the stronger option for kids’ spaces, where walls are constantly abused. It can handle crayon drawings, sticky fingers, and frequent scrubbing without breaking down.
Parents often appreciate how easy it is to clean, since a damp sponge or cloth quickly removes most messes. For durability and peace of mind, SuperPaint is the clear winner here.
Cost and Long-Term Value
Cost is another big difference between these paints. On average:
- Cashmere: Costs a bit more per gallon, but you’re paying for a refined finish and a soft feel.
- SuperPaint: A more budget-friendly option while still delivering good quality.
In the long run, both paints are durable, but Cashmere offers a higher aesthetic payoff, while SuperPaint stretches your budget further.
Which One Should You Choose?
Here’s a breakdown of when each paint works best:
Choose Cashmere if:
- You’re painting living rooms, bedrooms, or spaces where appearance matters.
- You want a smooth, professional-looking finish without hiring a pro.
- You’re okay spending a bit more for a high-end look.
Choose SuperPaint if:
- You’re painting kids’ rooms, hallways, or other busy spaces.
- You want durable walls that can handle scrubbing and daily wear.
- You’re working on a large project and want to save money.
Cashmere is renowned for its smooth texture, while SuperPaint is distinguished by its exceptional durability.
If you’re also comparing premium finishes, the Cashmere vs Emerald discussions offer a closer look at how these two high-end options differ in appearance and performance.
Final Thoughts
Painting with Sherwin-Williams Cashmere and SuperPaint taught me something simple: walls don’t just change how a room looks, they change how it feels.
When I walk into my living room, the Cashmere finish always makes the space feel softer and more polished.
In the hallway, where backpacks and shoes constantly scrape the walls, SuperPaint’s toughness has saved me from constant touch-ups.
In the end, I don’t think there’s a wrong choice here; only what fits your space and your lifestyle best. Both Cashmere and SuperPaint have earned my trust.
Try what you feel is best, or create a combination of both.
Have you tried Cashmere, SuperPaint, or another finish in your home? Share your experience; I’d love to hear how the right paint changed your space.
