I used to stare at my outdated brick fireplace every day, wishing it matched my style. If you’re doing the same, you’re not alone. That red brick probably feels heavy and out of place.

Here’s what I found– you don’t need to tear it down or spend thousands to get the fireplace you want.

I’ll show you everything I’ve learned about converting your brick fireplace yourself. You’ll get budget-friendly paint ideas, impressive stone veneer options, step-by-step instructions, money-saving tips, and common mistakes to avoid.

Ready to turn that eyesore into your living room’s focal point? Let’s do this.

Brick Fireplace Makeover Options

Update your outdated brick fireplace into a remarkable focal point with these creative renovation approaches that can dramatically change your space without breaking the budget.

1. Painting Your Brick Fireplace

Painting is the most popular and cost-effective way to refresh a fireplace. Chalk paint creates a matte farmhouse finish without primer and can be distressed for character.

Whitewashing involves mixing paint and water to achieve a translucent, weathered look that highlights the brick texture.

Regular latex paint with primer offers complete coverage in any color, while milk paint provides a natural chalky finish with adjustable opacity levels.

2. Adding a Stone Veneer or Stucco

Stone veneer and stucco add dramatic texture over existing brick. Stone veneer offers versatile designs and better insulation while being lighter than natural stone. Stucco creates smooth, contemporary finishes with endless customization options.

Both add home value and durability with less maintenance than paint. Professional installation is recommended for heat resistance and proper preparation.

3. Installing a New Mantel or Surround

Installing a new mantel not only upgrades your fireplace but also adds display space. Traditional wood mantels with detailed molding are well-suited for classic homes, while modern floating mantels offer clean lines for contemporary spaces. Rustic beam mantels bring farmhouse charm using reclaimed wood.

Stone or concrete mantels provide architectural presence for modern homes, while metal mantels offer industrial appeal at budget-friendly prices.

Step-by-Step Guide for a DIY Brick Makeover

Refresh your brick fireplace with this guide, covering everything from prep to styling. The process takes a weekend and can dramatically update your space.

Step 1: Prepare the Area and Clean the Brick

Remove all furniture and décor from around the fireplace. Lay down drop cloths to protect the flooring and surrounding surfaces.

Clean the brick thoroughly using a stiff brush and warm, soapy water to remove soot, dirt, and grease.

For stubborn stains, use a mixture of trisodium phosphate (TSP) and water. Allow the brick to dry completely, which may take 24-48 hours depending on humidity.

Step 2: Make Necessary Repairs and Primer if Needed

Fill any cracks or gaps in the mortar joints with appropriate filler or caulk. Sand down any rough or uneven areas. If you’re painting, apply a high-quality masonry primer designed for brick surfaces.

This step is crucial for paint adhesion and may require two coats for optimal coverage. Skip this step if you’re applying stone veneer or stucco.

Step 3: Apply Your Chosen Paint Finish

For paint, use a brush or roller designed for textured surfaces, working the paint into all the brick crevices. Apply thin, even coats rather than one thick coat.

For stone veneer, start at the bottom and work upward, applying adhesive and pressing each piece firmly. For stucco, apply the base coat with a trowel in smooth, even strokes.

Step 4: Add Texture or Second Coats

If painting, apply additional coats as needed for full coverage, allowing proper drying time between coats. For stone veneer, apply grout between pieces using a grout bag or trowel.

For stucco, add your finish coat and create the desired texture using tools like brushes, sponges, or trowels while the material is still workable.

Step 5: Install New Mantel or Surround (if applicable)

Measure and mark mounting points for your new mantel, ensuring it’s level and adequately anchored to wall studs.

Use the appropriate fasteners based on your wall type and the weight of the mantel. Install any decorative trim or molding pieces, ensuring joints are tight and properly aligned.

Step 6: Style and Accessorize

Once everything is completely dry and cured, add your finishing touches. Install new fireplace screens, tools, or accessories. Arrange decorative items on the mantel, considering scale and balance.

Add lighting, artwork, or plants around the fireplace area to complete the makeover and create a cohesive look with your room’s décor.

Before and After: Brick Fireplace Renovations

These brilliant before-and-after Renewations show how simple updates can completely revolutionize your brick fireplace, turning outdated eyesores into beautiful focal points that enhance your entire living space.

1. Classic Whitewash Makeover

Before: Dark, dated red brick that made the room feel closed in and heavy.

After: A bright, airy whitewashed brick that opens up the space and creates a fresh, coastal vibe.

2. Chalk Paint Modern Makeover

Before: Grimy, discolored brick that looked neglected and outdated.

After: Crisp, matte chalk-painted finish that delivers a clean, contemporary look with farmhouse charm.

3. Faux Stone Veneer Update

Before: Boring, flat brick that lacked character and visual interest.

After: Rich textured stone veneer that adds depth, warmth, and upscale appeal to the room.

4. Black Painted Brick with Wood Mantel

Before: Standard red brick with a dated, deteriorating mantel that felt tired.

After: Dramatic black brick paired with warm wood creates a striking, refined focal point.

5. Stucco Over Brick Makeover

Before: Chunky, overwhelming brick that dominated the room with its bulk.

After: Sleek stucco finish that streamlines the fireplace and gives it a modern, minimalist appeal.

6. Exposed Brick with New Mantel

Before: Painted-over brick with a clunky mantel that hid the natural beauty.

After: Restored original brick paired with a clean wood mantel for authentic farmhouse style.

7. Stone Surround and Painted Hearth

Before: Massive red brick fireplace with a tiny hearth that felt disproportionate.

After: Enhance the stone surround with an extended painted hearth, achieving a perfect scale and luxurious appeal.

What to Consider When Renovating a Fireplace

A successful fireplace renovation requires careful planning of your budget, materials, and tools. Informed choices prevent costly mistakes and ensure professional results that boost your home’s value.

Budgeting for Your Fireplace Makeover

Careful budget planning ensures your fireplace renovation stays on track without unexpected costs. Expenses vary based on the scope and materials selected.

Cost Breakdown for Various Makeover Options:

Plan your fireplace makeover budget with these typical cost ranges for popular renovation options.

Option	Cost Range (Low)	Cost Range (High)
Materials	$50	$200
Labor	$2/sq ft	$4/sq ft
Painting	$50	$200
Stone Veneer	$500	$1,500
Stucco	$200	$600
New Mantel	$150	$800
Supplies	$50	$100

Consider both materials and labor costs when choosing the best makeover option for your budget.

How to Choose Materials and Products

Selecting quality materials ensures your fireplace makeover looks professional and lasts.

Paint Recommendations

• Best overall paint: Benjamin Moore Advance or Sherwin-Williams ProClassic for durability and smooth finish.
• Best chalk paint: Annie Sloan Chalk Paint or Rust-Oleum Chalked Paint for easy adhesion and a distressed look.
• Best primer: Kilz Adhesion Primer or Zinsser Bulls Eye 1-2-3 for superior bonding on brick.

Stone Veneer Options

• Best manufactured stone: Cultured Stone or Eldorado Stone for realistic textures and installation support.
• Budget-friendly option: GenStone or StoneWorks faux panels for a lower-cost, easier-to-install solution.
• Natural stone: Local quarry stone offers a unique character but may need professional help for installation.

Essential Tools and Supplies

• Painting tools: Angled brushes, texture rollers (¾-inch nap), and extension poles.
• Installation tools: Level, drill with masonry bits, circular saw with diamond blade, trowels.
• Safety equipment: Drop cloths, painter’s tape, safety glasses, dust masks, and work gloves.

Styling Your New Fireplace

Thoughtful styling reimagines your renovated fireplace into an impressive focal point through décor, furniture placement, and lighting.

• Mantel Styling: Use the rule of threes with varying heights, featuring a large anchor piece (such as a mirror/artwork), medium-sized objects (like vases/books), and small accents (like candles/plants). Leave space and swap seasonal pieces.
• Furniture Arrangement: Position seating 6-8 feet from the fireplace, angled for conversation. Match furniture size to the fireplace and add a coffee table while keeping sightlines clear.
• Lighting: Layer ambient lighting with table lamps and wall sconces. Use dimmers for adjustable levels; softer when the fireplace is on, brighter for other tasks.
• Accessories: Match your fireplace style with woven textures and wood for painted brick, and metal or leather for stone. Add throw pillows and blankets for comfort.
• Visual Balance: Balance the fireplace with artwork on other walls and soften edges with plants. Repeat accent colors from the fireplace materials for a cohesive design.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Avoid these critical fireplace makeover mistakes that can compromise safety, durability, and your final results.

• Surface prep: Clean brick thoroughly and always use primer to prevent peeling and ensure proper adhesion
• Wrong paint type: Use high-temperature paint near fireboxes, as regular paint creates safety hazards
• Safety shortcuts: Wait 12+ hours after fireplace use and ensure adequate ventilation during work
• Rushing the process: Allow materials to cure completely before using the fireplace again
• Skipping tests: Test colors on small areas first, since they appear different on brick surfaces.

Taking time for proper preparation and safety measures ensures your fireplace makeover looks great and lasts for years

Conclusion

I’ve seen brick fireplace makeovers completely change a room without breaking the bank. If you choose paint or stone veneer, you can create an amazing focal point in just a weekend.

Picture your renovated fireplace becoming the cozy heart of your home. With the guides I’ve shared, you’re now ready to tackle this project with confidence.

I’ve learned that proper preparation makes all the difference. Clean thoroughly, choose high-quality materials, and take your time with the process.

Ready for more inspiration? Check out other blogs for fresh home improvement ideas. Start your fireplace makeover today!