Reviewing Benjamin Moore’s Edgecomb Gray (HC-173)

Are you looking for a paint color that’s neither too warm nor too cold?

Benjamin Moore’s Edgecomb Gray might be the answer.

This gentle shade has become a favorite among homeowners and designers who want a versatile neutral.

In this guide, we’ll look at everything you should know about Edgecomb Gray – from its undertones to ideal lighting conditions. You’ll learn:

Which rooms work best with this color
How it changes in different types of light
What colors match well with it

I’ve spent years testing and using Benjamin Moore paints, including Edgecomb Gray, in various settings.

I’ll share honest observations about when this color shines and when you might want to pick something else.

By the end of this post, you’ll know if Edgecomb Gray is the right choice for your space.

Why Edgecomb Gray Is the Perfect Choice for Your Space?

Some paint colors can be tricky to work with, but Edgecomb Gray makes things simple.

This neutral tone sits between gray and beige, giving you a color that works in countless ways.

Here’s what makes it stand out:

It plays well with both modern and traditional furniture
The color stays true throughout the day
It makes small rooms feel bigger

Unlike pure grays that can feel cold or beige that might look dated, Edgecomb Gray brings warmth without being too heavy.

When I paint a living room with this shade, the walls seem to glow softly rather than shout for attention.

Think of it as a blank canvas that enhances everything around it.

Put it in a sunny kitchen, and it feels fresh.

Use it in a bedroom, and it creates a peaceful mood.

I’ve even seen it make narrow hallways feel more open and welcoming.

One thing that sets it apart is that you won’t need to repaint in a few years because this color has staying power.

It’s not tied to passing trends, which saves you time and money in the long run.

The Rich Undertones of Edgecomb Gray: What You Need to Know

When I first look at Edgecomb Gray, I notice its gentle mix of warm and cool tones.

This isn’t your typical gray paint – it has subtle hints that make it special.

Let’s break down what’s really in this color:

A soft gray base that keeps it neutral
Gentle beige undertones that add warmth
A touch of green that shows up in certain lights
Very faint purple notes emerge in the evening light

I’ve tested this color in many homes, and here’s what I’ve learned: The undertones aren’t strong enough to take over a room, but they add depth.

Think of it like adding a pinch of salt to a dish—you might not taste it directly, but it makes everything better.

The magic happens when sunlight hits the walls.

In morning light, you might catch those warm beige notes. By afternoon, the gray becomes more clear.

This shifting quality helps your room stay interesting throughout the day.

Here’s what makes it work: Unlike pure grays, which can feel flat, these undertones give Edgecomb Gray life without making it complicated.

You won’t see sudden surprises, like some colors that turn pink or yellow when you least expect them.

Remember this tip: If you’re worried about undertones, test the paint on different walls in your room.

Watch how it changes from morning to evening.

This will help you see exactly how the color will behave in your space.

The Psychology of Edgecomb Gray: How It Affects Your Mood

Colors can change how we feel in a room, and I’ve seen firsthand how Edgecomb Gray creates a sense of calm.

When you walk into a space painted with this shade, you might notice your shoulders relaxing without knowing why.

Here’s what makes this color so special for your well-being:

Creates a feeling of stability and balance
Helps reduce visual noise and stress
Makes rooms feel welcoming and safe
Supports focus and clear thinking

I’ve painted many bedrooms with Edgecomb Gray; clients often tell me they sleep better.

The color doesn’t demand attention – instead, it gives your eyes a resting place.

Think of it as a soft blanket for your walls.

Its neutral tone doesn’t overstimulate your senses, so you won’t feel tired looking at it, unlike brighter or darker colors that can wear on you over time.

I’ve noticed that people find it easier to concentrate in home offices.

The color quietly plays in the background, letting you focus on your work.

It’s like having a good friend who knows when to be quiet.

This shade helps guests feel at ease right away in living spaces.

I remember one client saying, “People used to visit for an hour—now they stay all afternoon, and I think it’s the walls!”

Where is Edgecomb Gray Best Used in an Interior?

From my years of painting homes, I’ve found that Edgecomb Gray works well in almost any room.

However, some spaces really bring out their best qualities.

Living Rooms and Family Rooms

I love using them in the main living areas.

The color stays steady as light changes throughout the day, making these busy spaces feel calm.

Your furniture and decor will stand out nicely against these walls.

Kitchens and Dining Areas

In kitchens, this color offers a clean look without feeling stark.

\I’ve noticed it pairs well with both white cabinets and darker wood tones.

Food looks great against this backdrop, too – a detail that matters more than you might think.

Bedrooms and Home Offices

Creates a peaceful sleeping environment
Helps maintain focus during work hours
Works with any bedding color
Makes the room feel larger

Hallways and Entryways

These spaces can be tricky to paint, but Edgecomb Gray makes them feel wider and more welcoming.

I’ve used it in narrow hallways, and it helps them feel less cramped.

Here’s a useful tip: While this color works in most spaces, I wouldn’t use it in rooms that require high energy, like a playroom.

It’s too subtle for that kind of space.

The best part?

It looks good in both small and large rooms.

In small spaces, it recedes walls, giving the illusion of more space.

In large spaces, it creates a cozy feeling without closing things in.

What Kind of Floors Would Look Best with Edgecomb Gray?

I’ve seen Edgecomb Gray paired with many floor types, and I’m happy to share what works best.

The right flooring can make this color shine even more.

Hardwood Floors

Natural wood tones match perfectly with this paint color.

I’ve found that medium-brown oak and maple look particularly good.

Dark walnut creates a nice contrast without feeling too stark.

Even light pine works well, adding warmth to the overall look.

Tile Options:

Gray stone-look tiles blend smoothly with the walls
Cream or beige tiles enhance the warm undertones
White marble adds a clean, fresh feel
Natural stone ties everything together

Carpet Choices

When it comes to carpets, keep it simple.

I suggest neutral tones that don’t clash with the walls.

Soft grays and taupes work great.

One tip: avoid very yellow-toned beige carpets, as they can make the wall color look off-color.

Luxury Vinyl and Laminate

These materials work well when they mimic natural wood or stone.

I often recommend wood-look vinyl in honey or ash tones.

They’re practical and look good with Edgecomb Gray.

Remember this rule of thumb: Bring a sample home if you’re unsure about a floor color.

Look at it next to your painted walls at different times of the day.

This simple step can save you from making an expensive mistake.

Top Color Combinations with Edgecomb Gray

After testing countless color combinations, I’ve found seven pairs that work exceptionally well with Edgecomb Gray.

Let me share these tried-and-true matches with you.

1. Crisp White

Clean white trim and doors make Edgecomb Gray walls look fresh and well-defined.

I often use Benjamin Moore’s White Dove for this combo.

It creates clear lines without harsh contrast.

2. Deep Navy Blue

Navy furniture or accents add depth without overwhelming the space.

The gray tones in both colors create a natural fit, while the contrast keeps things interesting.

3. Soft Sage Green

Green accents bring out the subtle green undertones in Edgecomb Gray.

I’ve found this combination makes rooms feel connected to nature without trying too hard.

4. Charcoal Gray

For a sophisticated look:

Use charcoal in smaller doses
Try it on accent furniture
Add it through artwork
Include it in textiles

5. Warm Brown

Natural wood tones pair beautifully with Edgecomb Gray.

Think wooden beams, furniture, or picture frames.

The warmth in both colors creates a cozy feel.

6. Matte Black

Black light fixtures, window frames, or door hardware pop against Edgecomb Gray without feeling stark.

This pairing adds modern touches while staying classic.

7. Soft Gold

Metallic gold accents through lighting fixtures or mirrors add warmth and shine.

The key is choosing brushed or matte finishes rather than bright, shiny ones.

Remember: Start with one or two accent colors and build from there.

Too many bold colors can overshadow the quiet beauty of Edgecomb Gray.

How to Incorporate Edgecomb Gray Into Your Home Decor

Over the years, I’ve learned many ways to bring Edgecomb Gray into homes beyond just wall paint.

Let me share some simple methods that have worked well for my clients.

Start Small

You don’t need to paint every wall right away. Try these easy starting points:

Paint one accent wall
Update a piece of furniture
Add throw pillows in this shade
Choose curtains in this color

Layer Different Textures

I’ve found that Edgecomb Gray looks better when used across different materials. Mix these elements:

Smooth painted walls
Textured throw blankets
Woven baskets
Plush rugs
Ceramic vases

Quick Tips for Success

Test paint samples on all walls before committing
Look at the color during different times of day
Match existing furniture before buying new pieces
Keep some white elements to maintain brightness

A final note: Consider the finish of your paint.

Eggshell works well in most rooms, while pearl or semi-gloss suits high-traffic areas better.

Edgecomb Gray vs. Other Warm Neutrals: A Comparison

Let me help you understand how Edgecomb Gray compares to other common neutral colors.

I’ve painted hundreds of rooms with these shades, and here’s what I’ve learned.

Popular Warm Neutrals Compared

Paint Color	Main Color Note	Light Behavior	Best Used In	Common Challenge
Edgecomb Gray	Balanced greige with soft warmth	Stays true throughout the day	Any room, very flexible	Can look flat in dark rooms
Revere Pewter	Darker greige, more gray	Changes more with lighting	Large, bright spaces	Too dark for small rooms
Swiss Coffee	Creamy white with yellow notes	Brightens in natural light	Smaller spaces	It can look too yellow at night
Agreeable Gray	True greige, less warmth	Consistent in most lights	Open floor plans	It can feel cold in north rooms
Natural Cream	More beige than gray	Warms up in the afternoon sun	South-facing rooms	Shows shadows easily

Extra Tips From My Experience

Edgecomb Gray needs less touch-up than most others
It hides wall imperfections better than lighter shades
The color matches more decor styles than typical beiges
It photographs well – helpful if you plan to sell your home

Conclusion

After working with Edgecomb Gray in countless homes, I can say it’s one of the most reliable paint colors.

Its gentle mix of gray and beige creates a welcoming feel in any room, from bright kitchens to cozy bedrooms.

What makes it special is how it shifts subtly throughout the day while remaining true to its warm, neutral nature.

Plus, it works with almost any decor style.

If you’re looking for a paint color that will withstand changing trends and continue to make your space feel and welcoming, Edgecomb Gray could be your answer.

Just remember to test it in your space first, as good lighting will help this color shine its best.

Want to learn more?

Leave a comment below about your experience with Edgecomb Gray.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will Edgecomb Gray Make My Small Room Look Smaller?

Not at all—this light, neutral shade recedes walls, creating an airy feeling that can make small spaces appear larger and more open.

Does Edgecomb Gray Work Well in Bathrooms?

Yes, it pairs beautifully with white fixtures and marble.

The color withstands humidity well and maintains its warmth even under bathroom lighting.

How Many Coats of Edgecomb Gray Do I Need?

Two coats typically provide perfect coverage.

Use a quality primer first, especially when covering darker colors or fresh drywall.