Comparing Cost: Metal Roof vs Shingle
Confused about which roof gives you the best bang for your buck? Choosing the right roofing material can impact your wallet for decades, not just during installation.
I’ll compare the cost of a metal roof vs shingle options to help you decide. You’ll find upfront prices, long-term expenses, and maintenance costs for both materials.
This comparison covers everything from initial installation to lifetime value and resale benefits. Different climates and budgets need different solutions for maximum savings.
Metal and shingle roofs each have unique advantages that appeal to different homeowners. Your roof is a major investment, so let’s make sure you choose wisely!
DISCLAIMER: The costs mentioned are estimated and may vary based on your location, contractor rates, and specific project requirements.
Metal Roof vs Shingle: Key Differences
Metal roofs use steel, aluminum, or copper panels that interlock or overlap across your roof surface. These roofs last for decades and effectively resist fire, hail, and strong winds.
Metal reflects heat, keeping homes cooler in the summer and significantly reducing energy bills. Installation costs more upfront, but it saves money over time through increased durability and efficiency.
Shingle roofs use layered asphalt, wood, or composite materials that overlap like fish scales. These roofs typically last much shorter and cost much less to install initially.
Shingles come in a variety of colors and styles to perfectly match different home designs. They absorb heat, making homes warmer in winter but hotter in summer months.
Factors Affecting Metal Roof Costs
Several things control how much you’ll pay for your new metal roof. I’ll show you the three most significant factors that make prices go up or down.
1. Material Type
The metal you pick affects your wallet more than you might think. Steel roofing costs the least at around $4–$10 per square foot installed.
Aluminum costs a bit more, ranging from $6 to $15 per square foot for most homes. Copper tops the price list, starting at about $15 and reaching $30 or even $40 per square foot. The length of time each material lasts and its appearance also affect these prices.
2. Roof Complexity
Simple, flat roofs save you money on both materials and work time. Steep slopes and lots of angles make installation harder and take much longer to finish. Basic roofs might only add $200–$500 in extra labor costs to your bill.
Complex shapes can result in $1,500–$3,000 more in installation fees for intricate work. Valleys and peaks need extra materials, which also bump up your total cost.
3. Installation and Location
Your location significantly affects the cost of metal roof installation. Shipping heavy materials to remote places costs more money than city deliveries. Big cities often have higher labor rates, which can increase your final bill.
Cheaper areas might offer complete installs starting from $7,500 for average roofs. Expensive cities can reach $25,000 or more for the same-sized roof project. Local building rules and contractor rates shape your final price.
Factors Affecting Shingle Roof Costs
Your shingle roof price depends on the quality you pick and the extras you add. Here is a breakdown of the main things that make your final bill go higher or lower.
1. Shingle Quality
Better shingles cost more upfront but offer longer life and a nicer appearance. Basic 3-tab shingles run $3–$6 per square foot, while construction or premium types cost more.
Shingles typically range from $5 to $10 per square foot for most home projects. Upgrading to higher-quality shingles for a mid-sized home can range from $7,500 to $24,000 in total. Your roof size and style choice really affect the final price.
2. Roofing Underlayment
Good underlayment protects your roof from water damage, but adds to your bill. Standard underlayment adds approximately $0.15–$0.40 per square foot to your project cost.
Premium synthetic or ice and water shields cost between $0.75 and $1.25 per square foot. For a 2,000 sq. ft. roof, that’s about $300–$2,500 extra, depending on what you choose.
3. Installation Price
Shingle roofs install faster than metal, which saves you money on labor costs. However, they need replacement more often, which adds costs over many years.
Labor accounts for approximately 60% of your total bill, ranging from $2 to $5 per square foot, typically. Most homeowners spend $7,500–$24,000 for a full installation, depending on roof complexity and your area.
Long-Term Considerations
When deciding between a metal or shingle roof, it’s essential to consider the costs, durability, and maintenance requirements. Here’s a quick comparison to help you understand the differences:
| Category | Metal Roof | Shingle Roof |
|---|---|---|
| Longevity and Durability | 30-50 years, weather-resistant, low repairs. | 20-30 years, weather damage, frequent repairs. |
| Maintenance Costs | Low maintenance, occasional touch-ups. | High maintenance, regular inspections. |
| Long-Term Financial Impact | Long-term savings, fewer replacements. | Lower upfront cost, higher long-term costs. |
| Resale Value and Market Impact | Increases value and is attractive in harsh climates. | May not add value, appeals to budget buyers. |
Now that you’ve seen the key differences, you can make a more informed decision about which roofing option suits your needs. Think about what matters most: upfront cost or long-term savings.
Are Metal Roofs Cheaper than Shingles
Metal roofs cost more upfront than shingle roofs when initially installed. In 2025, a complete metal roof averages $15,000–$30,000 for most homes. Shingle roofs typically range from $6,000 to $15,000 for the same-sized house.
Per square foot, metal roofing costs approximately $7–$14, while shingles typically cost $4–$6 to install. But here’s where things get interesting over time.
Shingles need replacement more often, so homeowners may spend $10,000–$30,000 over the course of 50 years. Metal roofs often require only the original investment since they last much longer.
Shingle roofs are initially cheaper, but metal roofs often prove to be more cost-effective in the long term. Fewer replacements and repairs make metal the smarter money choice for many homeowners.
Wrapping It Up
The debate over the cost of a metal roof versus shingles boils down to timing and priorities.
Initial costs favor shingles, but longevity and maintenance savings make metal roofing more attractive in the long term.
Metal roofs cost more upfront but last decades longer with minimal repairs needed. Shingle roofs may initially save money, but they require frequent replacements and higher maintenance expenses.
Both options have clear advantages depending on your specific situation and goals. Your climate, budget, and plans should guide your final decision here.
Contact a local roofing professional today for personalized estimates and expert advice. Comment below your thoughts!
